Lee Cashell, CEO Asia
Pacific Investment Partners: Mongolia
is a rare real estate market that offers both high rental yields and capital
appreciation. The key is finding the right local partner to manage your
property for you.
If you are a property investor, the
success story of Lee Cashell and his real estate business in Mongolia is bound
to pique your interest. Still unknown to many people, Mongolia is one of the
fastest growing economies in the world with a staggering GDP growth of 17.5% in
2011. Despite a recent decline in the economy due in part to a drop in commodities
prices, this mineral-rich country is still achieving an enviable 7% growth rate
and has a thriving property market in which Cashell is accruing wealth for his
clients who invested in Asia Pacific Investment Partners’ developments.
Formerly a private equity fund manager
in Hong Kong for JAFCO Investment Asia, Cashell has held various positions
within the investment banking industry in Asia as an economist, financial
analyst and corporate finance manager. He founded Asia Pacific Investment
Partners (APIP), a Mongolia-focused operating group in 2002. While APIP’s main
business lies with property development, the company owns a wide range of
subsidiaries including a real estate agency, a cement plant, a construction
company, and a non-banking financial institution.
Mongolia is still an exotic investment destination to many. How did you
first gain interest in the country?
I went to Mongolia 14 years ago, the
primary reason being that it was the only country I had not yet visited after a
long finance career in Asia. What I quickly realized was that with its rich
mineral reserves, Mongolia was likely to become another Perth or San Francisco with
a mining boom legacy that spawned numerous millionaires from real estate. With
USD $30,000 as my seed money, I started buying, refurbishing, and renting out
apartments which ended up yielding over 60% per annum. I brought this story to
the Mongolian tax office and when they said there was no capital gains tax, I
decided to stay and started the country’s first real estate agency. The rest is
history. APIP has been profitable every year for the past 14 years of operation,
our real estate agency is the largest in Mongolia, and we successfully acquired
a cement plant, a construction company, and a non-banking financial institution
to achieve a vertically integrated business model. We are currently the largest
foreign company operating outside of the mining sector in Mongolia.
What is the real estate market like in Mongolia?
Mongolia’s property market boasts
one of the highest cash rental yields in Asia as well as strong capital
appreciation prospects. From 2005 to 2013, the average annual rental yield from
residential space was around 11% across all of Ulaanbaatar; Since 2010, rental
yields from retail space have averaged a staggering 20% per year across the
city. Rapid growth in GDP per capita, disposable income, and real wages are
driving demand for high quality residential and retail space, which in turn is
increasing property values. Properties developed by APIP have achieved rental
yields between 12% and 45% per annum. Capital appreciation has also been
substantial, varying from 100% to as much as 400% over a 5 to 10 year period.
This high cash rental income coupled with strong capital growth performance
make unlevered IRRs of 25% readily achievable in the market.
Have you had any legal difficulties as a foreign businessman?
The legal system in Mongolia is
surprisingly clear cut and favorable for foreign investors. Foreigners enjoy
the same rights as local Mongolians in regards to property ownership. When you
purchase real estate, you are presented with an immoveable property certificate
that specifies you as the exclusive and rightful owner of the property. APIP once
had an incident where the city’s mayor tried to take our land unjustly. We took
him to court, and won the case within six months. A foreign company taking a
native Mongolian mayor to the city’s court and winning the case means a lot. We
have never had any serious legal issues during our 14 years of operation in the
country.
Are you seeing any decline in property values considering the current
situation of the economy?
It is true that the past year has not
been easy for Mongolia. GDP growth is estimated to have dropped to around 7% as
opposed to 17.5% in 2011, while FDI has also declined approximately 80% from
last year. We get a lot of questions from potential clients regarding these
troubling signs in the economy: wouldn’t property values fall? What we have
seen is internal demand pick up despite these economic headwinds, last year total
exports and consumption increased by 35% and 10% respectively. The 2014 balance
of trade was recorded as a USD $538m surplus, exceeding many people’s expectations.
The fact of the matter is that
Mongolia is already on track to harvest its mining wealth and the people’s
demand for higher quality living is increasing like nowhere else in Asia. We
are close to completing the Olympic Residence, our most expensive residential
apartment yet, and already sold about 60% to local Mongolians and 20% to
foreign investors. This is a considerable increase from our last development in
2010, the Regency Residence, of which only 30% of the buyers were Mongolians
despite the economy then growing at a much higher rate than it is now.
We have not seen any decline in demand
for luxury properties and foresee more capital appreciation as available land
is becoming scarce in the city center. With the government replacing the prime
minister and forming a new coalition to answer the people’s call for a revamp
of the economy and progress in negotiations with Rio Tinto at Oyu Tolgoi, one
of the largest copper mines in the world with an estimated value of USD $350bn,
I have optimistic views on a quick recovery for the economy and more upward
momentum for real estate prices.
Information
provided by the manager about the company discussed in this summary is not
intended to be nor should it be construed or used as, investment, tax or legal
advice, a recommendation, or an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to
buy, an interest, directly or indirectly. Any offer or solicitation
of an investment in or by the Company may be made only by delivery of Offering
Documents and documents attached as exhibits to the Offering Documents. You
should rely solely on those offering documents in making any investment
decision.
No
information made available on the following document is or purports to be
investment, tax or other advice or is intended to provide the basis of any
credit or other evaluation. Nor should any such information be considered a
recommendation by Trusted Insight (TI) or North Capital Private Securities (NCPS),
or any of its affiliates or their respective directors, officers, employees or
agents (or any related person or entity) to purchase or sell any securities.
Before entering into any particular transaction, you are advised to obtain such
independent financial, legal, accounting and other advice as may be appropriate
under the circumstances. In any event, any decision to enter into a transaction
will be yours alone, not based on information prepared or provided by this
document. TI, NCPS and Asia Pacific Investment Partners hereby disclaim any
responsibility to you concerning the characterization or identification of
terms, conditions, and legal or accounting or other issues or risks that may
arise in connection with any particular transaction or business strategy.
Neither TI, NCPS and Asia Pacific Investment Partners nor any of its affiliates
or their respective directors, officers, employees or agents (or any related
person or entity) accepts any responsibility for or shall have any liability in
respect of any use of any information or materials made available on the
following document. Nothing shall under any circumstances create any
implication that any information made available on the following document is
correct or accurate. Neither TI, NCPS nor any of its affiliates or their
respective directors, officers, employees or agents (or any related person or
entity) makes any representation or warranty with respect to any information
made available on the following document.